How Much Do Independent Insurance Agents Make?

Written by Matthew King, time it takes to read this article is  minute(s).


Over the next¬†nine years, the need for insurance agents is expected to grow by eight percent. This is faster than average. If you’re an insurance agent there will be opportunities available to you.

If you’re interested in becoming your own boss as an independent insurance agent, pay is a factor you need to consider. So, how much do independent insurance agents make?

Keep reading to learn the answer to that question and more in our comprehensive guide for insurance agents.

What Is the Difference Between an Independent Agent and a Captive Agent?

When it comes to insurance agents, there are two main categories: independent agents and captive agents. But what sets them apart? Let’s explore the key differences between these two types of professionals.

An independent agent operates as their own business entity, representing multiple insurance companies. They have the freedom to choose from a wide range of policies and coverage options to meet their clients’ needs.

This flexibility allows them to provide unbiased advice. It also helps them find the best solutions for each individual customer.

On the other hand, a captive agent works exclusively for one insurance company or agency. They are contracted by that company and can only sell its products. Although they know a lot about those options, they can’t suggest other choices from different insurers.

This distinction also affects how these agents earn income. Independent agents usually earn commissions based on the amount of sales or premiums from policies they sell across different companies.

Captive agents, on the other hand, receive a base salary. They also get extra incentives for meeting sales targets set by their employer.

How Do Independent Insurance Agents Make Money?

As an independent insurance agent, you may be wondering how exactly you make money. Well, the answer lies in commissions!

When you sell insurance policies to clients, you earn a commission based on the premiums they pay. Commissions are typically a percentage of the policy’s premium and can vary depending on the type of insurance.

Factors Affecting Independent Insurance Agent Income

When it comes to the income of independent insurance agents, there are several key factors that can have a significant impact. Understanding these factors is crucial for those considering a career in this field or aiming to increase their earnings.


Experience plays a vital role. The longer you work as an independent insurance agent, the more chances you’ll get to build your client base.

You’ll also have longer to establish yourself in the industry. This can lead to higher commissions and greater income potential over time.

Type of Insurance Factor

Another factor influencing income is the type of insurance products sold. Certain policies may offer higher commission rates than others. Choosing to specialize in areas such as life insurance or commercial property coverage could potentially result in higher earnings.

Geographic Location

Geographic location also plays a part in an independent insurance agent’s income. Agents working in larger cities or regions with high demand for insurance services may have access to more clients. Therefore they have greater earning potential compared to those operating in smaller markets.

Marketing Efforts

Marketing efforts can also impact an agent’s income. Agents who actively market themselves are likely to attract more clients and generate higher sales volumes. This ultimately leads to increased income.

Relationships With Clients

Maintaining strong relationships with existing clients is crucial for long-term success. By providing excellent customer service and regularly reviewing policy options for clients’ changing needs, agents can earn their trust and loyalty. This helps with maximizing renewal commissions.

How Does Commission Work for Independent Insurance Agents?

In order to understand how much independent insurance agents make, it’s important to grasp the concept of commission. Commission is essentially a percentage of the premium that an agent earns for selling an insurance policy. It serves as the primary source of income for independent agents.

The commission structure can vary depending on the type of insurance and the company they work with. Generally, most agents earn a commission between 10% and 20% for property and casualty policies like auto and home insurance. For life or health insurance policies, commissions are typically higher due to their complexity.

It’s also worth noting that some insurers have tiered commission structures, where agents receive higher rates based on achieving certain sales targets or volume thresholds. This incentivizes agents to sell more policies and provides opportunities for increased earnings.

First-Year Commissions

These commissions are a percentage of the premiums collected from the policies sold by agents during their first year with a client. Let’s dive into this important source of income for insurance agents.

First-year commissions provide a boost to an agent’s earnings in their initial year with a new policyholder. Insurance companies typically offer higher commission rates for first-year policies as an incentive for agents to bring in new business. The exact commission rate can vary depending on factors such as the type and size of the policy being sold.

For independent insurance agents, these first-year commissions can make up a substantial portion of their overall income. Agents work hard to build relationships with potential clients and convince them that their products are the best fit for their needs. When those efforts pay off and result in securing new policies, it translates into higher earnings through first-year commissions.

It is important to note that while these initial commissions can be lucrative, they are generally one-time payments. After the first year, renewal commissions come into play.

Renewal Commissions

While first-year commissions provide a boost to earnings, it’s the renewal commissions that keep the money flowing year after year.

Renewal commissions are payments that independent insurance agents receive for policies that they have previously sold and successfully renewed. These commissions serve as a reward for maintaining client relationships and ensuring policyholders continue to renew their coverage.

One advantage of renewal commissions is that they offer a predictable source of income. As long as clients remain satisfied with their policies and choose to renew them, agents can count on receiving these ongoing commission payments.

The amount an agent earns from renewal commissions varies depending on several factors such as:

  • The type of insurance policy
  • Premium value
  • Percentage set by the insurance company

Generally, these percentages range from 2% to 15%. However, some companies may offer higher rates based on performance or other incentives.

How Much Do Independent Insurance Agents Make?

When it comes to being an independent insurance agent, one of the burning questions on many people’s minds is how much money they can expect to make. Although there is no single answer, knowing the typical pay for independent insurance agents can give you an idea.

Specific numbers may vary widely depending on the factors mentioned earlier. However, industry data suggests that the annual compensation for independent insurance agents falls within the $24,000 to $107,500 range. The national average is $55,537.

But remember, these numbers are averages and your experience could be different.

Additional Earnings Opportunities for Independent Insurance Agents

As an independent insurance agent, there are plenty of opportunities to increase your earnings. While selling other products certainly helps, it’s not your only path.

Supplementary Products and Services

Many independent agents choose to offer supplementary products and services. This could include things like financial planning or retirement consulting.

By diversifying your offerings, you can attract a wider range of clients. This will help you generate additional revenue from these value-added services.


Networking is key in the insurance industry. It’s a good idea to build strong relationships with professionals like real estate agents or mortgage brokers. It can lead to referrals and cross-selling opportunities.


Consider becoming a specialist in a particular niche market or industry. By focusing on specific sectors such as healthcare or construction, you can develop expertise that sets you apart from generalist agents. These specialized skills can enable you to command higher fees and earn more lucrative commissions.

Use Technology to Your Advantage

Take advantage of the technology tools available today. They can help you streamline your operations and maximize efficiency.

Invest in customer relationship management (CRM) software. Look for tools that help track leads and automate follow-ups effectively.

When you use these digital tools well, you’ll have more time for getting new business and making more money.

Ongoing Education and Professional Development

Stay ahead of industry trends by attending conferences or taking advanced courses.

This helps demonstrate a commitment to excellence in your field. Ultimately, it can translate into higher client satisfaction rates and increased referrals.

Never stop learning! Stay up-to-date with industry trends by attending conferences or workshops regularly. Make sure you continuously invest time into professional development.

It helps enhance personal skill sets while keeping abreast of changes within this ever-evolving field.

Strategies to Maximize Income as an Independent Insurance Agent

As an independent insurance agent, you have the potential to earn a significant income. However, maximizing your earnings requires careful planning and strategic approaches. Here are some strategies that can help you boost your income as an independent insurance agent.

Build Strong Relationships With Your Customers

It’s essential to focus on building strong relationships with your clients. Providing exceptional customer service and being proactive in meeting customers’ needs will help you:

  1. Increase client retention rates
  2. Generate more referrals

Happy clients are more likely to refer their friends and family to you. This can lead to additional sales opportunities.

Expand Your Product Knowledge

Expanding your product knowledge is crucial for increasing sales. Take the time to educate yourself about different types of insurance policies and coverage options.

This will enable you to offer comprehensive solutions tailored to each client’s specific needs. It could also potentially result in higher commissions.

Marketing Strategies

Traditional marketing methods like cold calling or direct mail campaigns can help. However, embracing digital marketing strategies can significantly impact your bottom line.

Utilize social media platforms like LinkedIn or Facebook ads. These platforms can target specific demographics that align with your target market audience.

In addition, create informative blog posts or host webinars and showcase your expertise within the industry. This can help attract potential customers while establishing credibility among existing ones.

Data Analytics

Utilize data analytics to gain a better understanding of your customer base and their behavior. Analyzing customer buying patterns can help identify trends and preferences. This allows you to tailor your marketing strategies to target these specific areas more effectively.

Referral Programs

Implement referral programs for satisfied customers or business partners. They can help promote your services through word-of-mouth recommendations.

Building Your Online Presence

In today’s digital age, having a strong online presence is essential for any business. Start by creating a professional website. Make sure it showcases the following:

  • Services
  • Past successes
  • Contact information

Utilize search engine optimization (SEO) techniques. This can help improve your website’s visibility on search engines like Google.

Additionally, claim and optimize your business listings. You can do this on various online directories such as Yelp or Google My Business.

Partnering with Other Professionals

Working with professionals in similar fields can help you make more connections and reach more people. Look at industries like real estate agents or contractors. Consider offering referral incentives to encourage these partnerships.

Collecting Reviews and Testimonials

To gain the trust of potential customers, positive reviews and testimonials from happy clients are crucial. Encourage happy clients to leave reviews. They can leave them on your website, social media pages, and online directories.

Find Opportunities to Expand Your Earning Potential

How much do independent insurance agents make? The income potential for independent insurance agents can vary greatly.

It depends on various factors such as experience, location, and product offerings. While there is no fixed salary for independent agents, their earnings primarily come from commissions earned on sales.

If you’re ready to expand your knowledge, Insurance Sales 101 is here to help you. We offer coaching, training, guidance, and tips for independent agents and agency owners. We’re here to help you make your business as profitable as possible.

Enroll today with a one-time fee and enjoy our current and future courses.

Join Insurance Advisor Elite

All access-pass to all courses, resources, sales systems, bonus content, and digital tools.

{"email":"Email address invalid","url":"Website address invalid","required":"Required field missing"}